"Tom Dooley" is an old North Carolina folk song based on the
1866 murder of a woman named Laura Foster in Wilkes County,
North Carolina. It is best known today because of a hit version
recorded in 1958 by The Kingston Trio. This version was a
multi-format hit, reaching #1 in Billboard, the Billboard
R&B listing, and appearing in the Cashbox country music top
20.
It was selected as one of the Songs of the Century by the
Recording Industry Association of America (RIAA), the National
Endowment for the Arts, and Scholastic Inc.
In the documentary
Appalachian Journey(1991), folklorist Alan Lomax
describes Frank Proffitt as the "original source" for the song.
Since the song predates Frank Proffitt's early version, it
appears that Lomax means that Proffitt's version is the one
that has become most well known to us because the Kingston Trio
derived their interpretation from it. Certainly, there is at
least one earlier known recording, by Grayson and Whitter made
in 1929, approximately 10 years before Proffitt cut his own
recording.
Impoverished Confederate veteran Tom Dula (Dooley), Laura
Foster's lover and probable fiancé, was convicted of her murder
and hanged in 1868. Foster was stabbed to death with a large
knife; the brutality of the attack partly accounted for the
widespread publicity the murder and subsequent trial
received.
Dula had a second lover, Anne Melton. It was her comments
that led to the discovery of Foster's body, but Melton was
acquitted in a separate trial based on Dula's word. Dula's
enigmatic statement on the gallows that he had not harmed
Foster but still deserved his punishment led to press
speculation that Melton was the actual killer and that Dula
simply covered for her. Melton, who had once expressed jealousy
of Dula's purported plans to marry Foster, died insane a few
years after the homicide. Thanks to the efforts of newspapers
such as
The New York Times, and to the fact that former North
Carolina governor Zebulon Vance represented Dula
pro bono, Dula's murder trial and hanging were given
widespread national publicity. A local poet, Thomas C. Land,
wrote a popular song about Dula's tragedy after the
hanging.
A man named "Grayson," mentioned in the song as pivotal in
Dula's downfall, has sometimes been characterized as a romantic
rival of Dula's or a vengeful sheriff who captured him and
presided over his hanging. Some variant lyrics of the song
portray Grayson in that light, and the spoken introduction to
the Kingston Trio version did the same. Col. James Grayson was
actually a Tennessee politician who had hired Dula on his farm
when the young man fled North Carolina under suspicion and was
using a false name. Grayson did help North Carolinians capture
Dula and was involved in returning him to North Carolina, but
otherwise played no role in the case.
Dula was tried in Statesville, because it was believed he
could not get a fair trial in Wilkes County. He was given a new
trial on appeal but he was again convicted, and hanged on May
1, 1868. His alleged accomplice, Jack Keaton, was set free. On
the gallows, Dula reportedly stated, "Gentlemen, do you see
this hand? I didn't harm a hair on the girl's head."
Dula's last name was pronounced "Dooley," leading to some
confusion in spelling over the years. (The pronunciation of a
final "a" like "y" is an old feature in Appalachian speech, as
in the term "Grand Ole Opry"). The confusion was probably
compounded by the fact that Dr. Tom Dooley, an American
physician known for international humanitarian work, was at the
height of his fame in 1958, when the Kingston Trio version
became a major hit.
The doleful ballad was probably first sung shortly after the
execution and is still commonly sung in North Carolina.
Several notable recordings have been made:
Tom Dooleyprompted a number of parodies, either as part
of other songs (Ella Fitzgerald drops an altered line from the
song into a recording of
Rudolph the Red-Nosed Reindeer) or as entire songs,
including one called
Hang Down Your Head Tom Dooley, Your Tie's Caught In Your
Zipperby the Incredible Bongo Band in 1972.
The song and legend were parodied by a one-record novelty
act called Waldo, Dudley and Dora on a 45 rpm
Grayson Goofed, issued as Awful Records release #PU-1.
Verses sung to the Tom Dooley melody alternate with mini-skits,
as "John" Grayson's public reputation erodes from "a fine man"
to "a stoolie" (i.e., stool pigeon) to "a gink".
The song was often parodied by the Smothers Brothers as
Tom Crudely.
In Episode #705 of
Mystery Science Theater 3000, Crow T. Robot, motivated
by one actor's resemblance to Thomas Dewey, sang a version
beginning "Hang down your head,
Tom Dewey."
In Ally McBeal (season 5 episode 18) Tom Dooley is the name
of the episode in which John Cage sings a version of the song
with his Mexican band.
The Kingston Trio hit inspired a quickie feature film,
The Legend of Tom Dooley(1959), starring actor Michael
Landon, with a cast including Richard Rust. The film was
essentially a Western set just after the Civil War. Despite the
title, it was not about any traditional Tom Dula legends or
about the facts of the actual case, but was a fictional
treatment obviously tailored to fit the lyrics of the song.