"Papa Don't Preach" is a dance-pop song by American singer
and songwriter Madonna. The song was written by Brian Elliot
with additional lyrics by Madonna, and produced by Stephen Bray
and Madonna for her third studio album
True Blue, released in June 1986. The song also appears
remixed on the 1990 compilation album
The Immaculate Collectionand in its original form on the
2009 compilation album
Celebration. The song's musical style combines pop and
classical rhythms, and its lyrics deal with teenage pregnancy
and abortion. The music video, directed by James Foley, shows
Madonna's second image makeover, featuring her with a more
toned and muscular body, and cropped platinum blonde hair.
Released as the album's second single in mid-1986, the song
was a commercial success. It became Madonna's fourth number-one
single on the Hot 100, and performed well internationally,
reaching the top position in Australia and the United Kingdom.
It was generally well-received by music critics and was
frequently cited as a highlight in the album.
Shortly after its release, the song caused heated
discussions about its lyrical content. Women's organizations
and others in the family planning field criticized Madonna for
encouraging teenage pregnancy, while groups opposed to abortion
saw it as a positive pro-life message. The song also caused her
first conflict with the Vatican, as she dedicated the song to
Pope John Paul II, who urged Italian fans to boycott her
concerts during the Who's That Girl World Tour in 1987.
During the autumn of 1985, Madonna started writing and
recording songs for her third studio album,
True Blue. She brought back Steve Bray and hired a new
songwriter collaborator, Patrick Leonard, to help her co-write
eight of the album's nine tracks. The album's first track "Papa
Don't Preach", was written by Brian Elliot, who described it as
"a love song, maybe framed a little bit differently". The song
is based on teen gossip he heard outside his studio, which has
a large front window that doubles as a mirror where schoolgirls
from the North Hollywood High School in Los Angeles regularly
stopped to fix their hair and chat. The song was sent to
Madonna by Michael Ostin, the same Warner Bros. executive that
discovered "Like a Virgin". Madonna only contributed with some
minor lyrical revisions, making "Papa Don't Preach" the only
song in the album that she did not have a strong hand in
writing. In 2009, during an interview with
Rolling StoneMadonna was asked by the interviewer Austin
Scaggs as to why the theme of the song was meaningful to her.
She replied saying,
"[The song] just fit right in with my own personal zeitgeist
of standing up to male authorities, whether its the pope, or
the Catholic Church or my father and his conservative,
patriarchal ways. [...] For 'Papa Don't Preach' there were so
many opinions – that's why I thought it was so great. Is she
for 'schma-smortion', as they say in
Knocked Up? Is she against abortion etc."
"Papa Don't Preach" is a dance-pop song with instrumentation
from acoustic, electric, and rhythm guitars, keyboards, and
string arrangements. It is set in common time, and moves at a
moderate tempo of 116 beats per minute. The song is written in
the key of F minor, an unusual choice for a pop song, but
commonly used in classical music, like Beethoven's
Appassionatasonata. The combination of key and tempo
produces a disjuncture between pop and classical rhythms,
underlined by the instrumentation during the introduction.
The song begins with a distinctly Vivaldian style, as the
fast tempo and classical-style chord progression anticipates
the lyrics to follow. The opening chords and the melody
emphasize the tonic of the leading notes: Fm–E
♭
–D
♭
–Cm–D
♭
–E
♭
–Fm–D
♭
–E
♭
–Fm, resembling a Baroque work. This is followed by the
sound of dance music, produced by a powerful beat from the
instruments. Madonna's vocal range spans from F
3to C
5, and has a different sound from her previous work,
more mature, centered, and with a lower range.
The lyrics show Madonna's interest in her Roman Catholic
upbringing, as the song theme is about a teenage girl who
admits to her father that she is pregnant and refuses to have
an abortion or give up the baby for adoption despite what her
friends are telling her to do.
It is constructed in a verse-chorus form, with a bridge
before the third and final chorus. At the beginning, she
addresses her father directly, asking him to talk to her as an
adult, "You should know by now that I'm not a baby". The
transition to the chorus employs a more dramatic voice with a
higher range, ending nearly in cries as she sings the word
"Please". Leading to the chorus, Madonna switches to a pleading
voice, singing the song's main hook in a high tone. During the
bridge, the song features a Spanish-inspired rhythm, one of the
earliest examples of the influence that Hispanic music had on
Madonna's musical style.
"Papa Don't Preach" was generally well-received by pop music
critics. Davitt Sigerson from
Rolling Stonemagazine in a review of the album
True Bluesaid that if there is a problem with the album
"it's the lack of outstanding songs", adding that "only the
magnificent 'Papa Don't Preach' has the high-profile hook to
match 'Like a Virgin', 'Dress You Up' and 'Material Girl'." In
its review of
True Blue, Allmusic's Stephen Thomas Erlewine said that
"she is using the music to hook in critics just as she's
baiting a mass audience with such masterstrokes as 'Papa Don't
Preach'." Robert Christgau in a review for
The Village Voicefelt that "she [Madonna] doesn't speak
for the ordinary teenaged stiff any more", adding that the
"antiabortion content of 'Papa Don't Preach' isn't unequivocal,
and wouldn't make the song bad by definition if it were, the
ambiguity is a cop-out rather than an open door, which is
bad."
Sal Cinquemani from Slant Magazine said that "with songs
like 'Papa Don't Preach', Madonna made the transition from pop
tart to consummate artist, joining the ranks of 80s icons like
Michael Jackson and Prince." David Browne from
Entertainment Weeklyin a review of her first compilation
album
The Immaculate Collection, commented that "in theory a
30-ish urban sophisticate singing in the voice of a pregnant
teen, sounds ridiculous", but added that "with the help of
collaborators like Stephen Bray and Patrick Leonard, though,
turns into a perfectly conceived pop record".
Blender's Tony Power said that the "baroque faux strings
and abortion dilemma of 'Papa Don’t Preach' herald a new, less
querulous Madonna, girlishly in love with Sean Penn and
bolstered by writer-producer Pat Leonard." In 2005, the same
magazine placed the song at number 486 on its list of "The 500
Greatest Songs Since You Were Born". In 1987, the song was
nominated for Best Female Pop Vocal Performance at the 29th
Grammy Awards, but lost to Barbra Streisand's
The Broadway Album.
"Papa Don't Preach" was released in the United States in
June 1986. It debuted on the Hot 100 at number forty-two, and
within eight weeks of its release, it had reached the top of
the chart, making it Madonna's fourth number-one single in the
U.S. It maintained the top position for two weeks, and spent
eighteen weeks on the chart. In October 1998, the single was
certified gold by the Recording Industry Association of America
(RIAA). In Canada the song debuted at the fifty-three position
of the
RPMsingles chart on July 5, 1986, reached the top for
two weeks in August 1986, and stayed on the chart for twenty
weeks.
In the United Kingdom "Papa Don't Preach" was released on
June 23, 1986. The next week the song debuted at number
thirteen on the UK Singles Chart, before climbing to number one
two weeks later. It then spent three consecutive weeks at the
top, stayed fifteen weeks on the chart, and was certified gold
by the British Phonographic Industry (BPI) in August 1986.
Across Europe, "Papa Don't Preach" was successful, topping the
Eurochart Hot 100 for eleven weeks. It reached the top position
of the singles charts in Belgium, Ireland, Italy, and Norway,
and peaked inside the top five in Austria, France, Germany, the
Netherlands, and Switzerland.
For the music video Madonna sported a complete image
makeover. She changed the heavy jewelry and make-up, and
adopted the gamine look, which is notably applied to describe
the style and appearance that Shirley MacLaine and Audrey
Hepburn used during the 1950s. In the video Madonna played a
tomboy, dressed in jeans, a black leather jacket, and a slogan
T-shirt that announced "Italians do it Better". The video
alternated between tomboy shots and those of a sexier Madonna
with a more toned and muscular body, cropped platinum blonde
hair, and figure-revealing clothing, consisting of a
1960s-style black bustier top and capri pants. It was directed
by James Foley, produced by David Naylor and Sharon Oreck, and
Michael Ballhaus was in charge of the photography.
It starts with shots of the New York skyline, the Staten
Island Ferry, and character close-ups. Madonna plays a
teenager, who is seen walking along a lane. Then it shows her
thinking about her father, played by Danny Aiello, and how much
he loves her. She then sees her boyfriend, played by actor Alex
McArthur, coming along. The images are juxtaposed with shots of
Madonna dancing and singing in a small, darkened studio.
Madonna then moves away from her friends, who warn her from her
boyfriend. She and her boyfriend spend a romantic evening
together on a barge where they reflect upon their lives after
watching an elderly couple. Then Madonna finds out that she is
pregnant and after much hesitation tells her father. They have
a few days of tension between them. Her father eventually
accepts the pregnancy, and the final scene is a reconciliatory
embrace between father and daughter.
At the 1987 MTV Video Music Awards, the "Papa Don't Preach"
video won the Best Female Video award, and was nominated for
Best Cinematography and Best Overall Performance.
Madonna has performed the song on three of her world tours.
She premiered the song in 1987, during her Who's That Girl
World Tour, where she danced around the stage wearing a white
Spanish-style dress designed by Marlene Stewart, and a black
leather jacket similar to the one she used in the music video.
The screen in the background showed portraits of Pope John Paul
II and then-President of the U.S. Ronald Reagan, along with
scenes of John Perry III's short film,
The Nightmare, ending with the words "Safe Sex", as
Madonna finished the song. She dedicated the song to the Pope,
marking her first conflict with the Vatican, as Pope John Paul
II urged Italian fans to boycott her concerts. Two different
performances of the song on this tour can be found on the
videos:
Who's That Girl - Live in Japan, filmed in Tokyo, Japan,
on June 22, 1987, and
Ciao, Italia! - Live from Italy, filmed in Turin, Italy,
on September 4, 1987.
Three years later on her Blond Ambition World Tour, Madonna
evoked Catholic images during the "Papa Don't Preach"
performance. She wore a black kaftan and energetically danced
with an accompaniment of six male dancers, with a platform full
of votive candles in the background. Two different performances
were taped and released on video, the
Blond Ambition - Japan Tour 90, taped in Yokohama,
Japan, on April 27, 1990, and the
Live! - Blond Ambition World Tour 90, taped in Nice,
France, on August 5, 1990. In 2004, during the Re-Invention
World Tour, Madonna performed the song wearing a Scottish kilt,
and a T-shirt that said "Kabbalists do it Better" on most of
the shows, and "Brits do it Better" and "Irish do it Better"
T-shirts during the shows in the United Kingdom and Ireland,
reminiscent of the one she used in the song's music video.
"Papa Don't Preach" has been covered by numerous artists. In
2002, British singer Kelly Osbourne recorded together with
Incubus' members Mike Einziger (guitar), and Jose Pasillas
(drums), a hard-rock cover of the song that was produced by her
brother Jack Osbourne. It was included as a bonus track on her
debut album
Shut Upand on the soundtrack of MTV's reality television
program
The Osbournes. The song was released in the United
Kingdom on September 2002, peaking at number three. In the rest
of Europe, the song peaked inside the top ten in Ireland and
Finland, and the top twenty in Sweden. In Australia the song
debuted at number three, and received a platinum certification
by the Australian Recording Industry Association (ARIA). This
version was panned by music critics, who thought that the cover
"makes precisely zero sense", and that it "reeks of
opportunism", also criticizing Incubus' collaboration,
describing it as "unimaginative", and that "their presence
makes the whole mess barely distinguishable".
French group Mad'House made an Eurodance cover of the song,
that was included on their 2002 album
Absolutely Mad. Covers of the song on tribute albums
include Brook Barros on
The Music of Madonna, released in 2005, and a jazz
version on Bo. Da's
Plays Madonna in Jazz, released in 2007. The song has
been sampled at the beginning of Mario Winans' 2004 single
"Never Really Was", and a slowed down version by Keshia Chante
sample the song in the 2006 single "Fallen" The television show
Glee released a cover version performed by Dianna Agron.
As the song's popularity increased in the U.S., so did the
criticism and support it received from groups concerned with
pregnancy and abortion. In July 1986, shortly after the release
of the video for "Papa Don't Preach", Madonna commented on the
controversy surrounding the song, to music critic Stephen
Holden from
The New York Times:
"Papa Don't Preach" is a message song that everyone is going
to take the wrong way. Immediately they're going to say I am
advising every young girl to go out and get pregnant. When I
first heard the song, I thought it was silly. But then I
thought, wait a minute, this song is really about a girl who is
making a decision in her life. She has a very close
relationship with her father and wants to maintain that
closeness. To me it's a celebration of life. It says, 'I love
you, father, and I love this man and this child that is growing
inside me'. Of course, who knows how it will end? But at least
it starts off positive.
People that criticized the song's message include Ellen
Goodman, a national syndicated columnist, who called the video
"a commercial for teenage pregnancy". Feminist lawyer Gloria
Allred, the spokeswoman of the National Organization of Women
(NOW), angrily called for Madonna to make a public statement or
another record supporting the opposite point of view. Alfred
Moran, the executive director of Planned Parenthood of New York
City, also criticized the song, fearing that it would undermine
efforts to promote birth control among adolescents and that it
would encourage teenage pregnancy. Recalling how his agency's
clinics were filled in 1985 with girls wearing clothes that
were an imitation of Madonna's style, Moran said that the
song's message is "that getting pregnant is cool and having the
baby is the right thing and a good thing and don't listen to
your parents, the school, anybody who tells you otherwise—don't
preach to me, Papa. The reality is that what Madonna is
suggesting to teenagers is a path to permanent poverty."
In contrast, groups opposed to abortion saw "Papa Don't
Preach" as a positive, pro-life song. Susan Carpenter-McMillan,
the president of the California chapter of Feminists for Life
(FFL) in the U.S., said that "abortion is readily available on
every street corner for young women. Now what Madonna is
telling them is, hey, there's an alternative." Tipper Gore, a
founder of the Parents Music Resource Center (PMRC), who a year
earlier denounced Madonna for the sexual lyrical content of her
single "Dress You Up", and had led a campaign against explicit
content in music, commended Madonna for speaking candidly about
such a serious subject and important social issue.
The song's writer, Brian Elliot, commented about the debate:
"I just wanted to make this girl in the song a sympathetic
character. As a father myself, I'd want to be accessible to my
children's problems." Madonna avoided the controversy, and did
not comment on the song's use as an anti-abortion statement.
Her publicist, Liz Rosenberg, said that "she [Madonna] is
singing a song, not taking a stand", adding that "her
philosophy is people can think what they want to think."