"Who's That Girl" is a song by American singer-songwriter
Madonna from the soundtrack album
Who's That Girlof the motion picture of same name. It
was released on June 30, 1987 by Sire Records as the first
single from the album. It later appeared on the 1991 UK
compilation EP
The Holiday Collection, which was released to accompany
the 1990 compilation album
The Immaculate Collection, and has since been included
on the two-disc edition of her 2009 greatest hits album
Celebration. While shooting for the film, then called
Slammer, Madonna had requested Patrick Leonard to
develop an uptempo song that captured the nature of her film
persona. She later added the lyrics and vocals to the demo tape
developed by Leonard, and decided to call both the song and the
movie "Who's That Girl".
Featuring instrumentation from drums, bass, and stringed
instruments, "Who's That Girl" continued Madonna's fascination
with Hispanic culture by incorporating Spanish lyrics and using
the effect of double vocals. Although it received mixed
reactions from reviewers, the song became Madonna's sixth
single to top the Hot 100, while peaking atop the charts in
countries like the United Kingdom, Canada, Netherlands, Ireland
and Belgium.
The music video portrayed a different persona of Madonna,
rather than her film character for which it was released. Like
the song, it incorporated Hispanic culture and portrayed her
dressed in Spanish style as a young lady in search of a
treasure. It was criticised for not depicting her real self.
Madonna performed the song once on the Who's That Girl World
Tour in 1987. The song has been covered by many artists and has
appeared in compilations and tribute albums.
In 1986, Madonna was shooting for her third motion picture
Who's That Girl, known at the time as
Slammer. Needing songs for the soundtrack of the movie,
she contacted Patrick Leonard and Stephen Bray, who had written
and produced her third studio album
True Bluein 1986. Madonna explained to them that she
needed an uptempo song and a downtempo song. She came to the
studio one Thursday as Leonard developed the chorus of the
song. He handed over that cassette to Madonna, who went to the
backroom and finished the melody and the lyrics of the song,
while Leonard worked on the other parts of the song. After
finishing the lyrics, Madonna declared that she wanted the song
to be named "Who's That Girl" and changed the movie to the
same, rather than
Slammer, considering it to be a better title. In Fred
Bronson's
The Billboard Book of Number 1 Hitsbook, Leonard
explained that the song was recorded in one day with Madonna
adding her vocals only once. Additional instrumental tracks
with guitars and percussion were included by Leonard and Bray
later. Regarding the development of the music for the film,
Madonna further explained
"I had some very specific ideas in mind, music that would
stand on its own as well as support and enhance what was
happening on screen and the only way to make that a reality was
to have a hand in writing the tunes myself. [...] The songs
aren't necessarily about Nikki [her character name in the
movie] or written to be sung by someone like her, but there's a
spirit to this music that captures both what the film and the
characters are about, I think."
The song is composed in Madonna's typical style—mingling the
drum machine, a bubbling bass synth line, and the sound of
stringed instruments. The three parts of the song, namely the
bridge, where Madonna sings "what can help me now", the chorus
and the verse flow together strongly. The chorus has a haunting
effect in it. The song epitomizes Madonna's interest with
Hispanic culture that continued after the release of "La Isla
Bonita", by adding Spanish phrases in the chorus and over the
trumpets of the second verse, and also by the added
instrumental break in the middle. It also uses the sonic effect
brought about by the combination of multiple vocal lines, which
had been previously used by groups like The Beach Boys in their
singles "God Only Knows" (1966) and "I Get Around" (1964) as
well as R.E.M.'s singles "Fall On Me" (1986) and "Near Wild
Heaven" (1991). "Who's That Girl" employs this effect on the
last chorus where three or four different vocal hooks are
intertwined.
Critical reaction to the song has been mixed. In his book
The Complete Guide to the Music of Madonna, author Rikky
Rooksby explained that the song was Madonna's best take on her
original music style. Stephen Thomas Erlewine of Allmusic
commented that "Who's That Girl" along with "Causing a
Commotion" were not amongst Madonna's best singles. Although
Tony Power of
Blendermagazine criticised the whole soundtrack, he
considered "Who's That Girl" to be its standout track.
Biographer J. Randy Taraborrelli, in his book
Madonna: An Intimate Biographycalled the song
"quintessential Madonna music" and went on to describe it as
"funky, sassy and melodic, with a Latin accent." Noah Robischon
from
Entertainment Weeklyopined that with the both the song
and the movie, Madonna had pushed "synergy over the
borderline." Bill Lamb of About.com said that the song, along
with the second single from the soundtrack "Causing a
Commotion", was not an example of Madonna's best music.
"Who's That Girl" was released in the United States in June
1987. It debuted on the Hot 100 at number forty-three, reached
the top of the chart in its seventh week, maintained the top
position for one week, and spent sixteen weeks on the chart. It
became Madonna's sixth number-one single in the United States,
making her the first artist to accumulate six number-one
singles in the 1980s, and the first female performer to get
that many number-ones as a solo act. The song peaked at number
two on the Hot Dance Club Play chart. In 2000, the song came
tenth in a vote conducted to determine the favourite Madonna
song.
In Canada, the song debuted at the eighty-third position of
the
RPMsingles chart on July 11, 1987, reached the top for
one week on August 29, 1987, and stayed on the chart for
twenty-three weeks. In the United Kingdom, "Who's That Girl"
was released on July 14, 1987, and debuted at number three on
the UK Singles Chart, soon climbing to number one the next week
to become Madonna's fifth number-one single in the United
Kingdom. Across Europe, "Who's That Girl" also topped the
singles charts in Belgium, Italy, Ireland, and the Netherlands,
as well as peaking in the top five in Austria, France, Germany,
Norway, Sweden, and Switzerland.
The music video was shot over two days, at Grayhall Mansion
in Beverly Hills, California. Madonna had adopted a garish,
platinum blond hairstyle for the
Who's That Girlmovie which she used in the music video;
it was her way of reviving the comedy heroine of the 1930s
Hollywood screwball comedies. She continued with her Hispanic
look from the "La Isla Bonita" music video, this time she
appeared dressed boyishly in a wide-brimmed Spanish hat and
bolero jacket—a combination which would later become a fashion
trend.
The music video, directed by Peter Rosenthal, begins with
Madonna entering a park. After meeting two children and a
teenage boy, they start roaming around the park, with Madonna
singing the song. These scenes are interchanged with scenes
from the motion picture, which show Madonna as the movie
character Nikki Fynn. As the music video progresses, Madonna is
shown to be in search of an Egyptian treasure casket. After
being directed to it by a postcard displaying her cartoon
impersonation, Madonna opens it to find a huge diamond. She
looks up happily to the children. The video ends with them
continuing dancing and Madonna carrying away the casket.
The video portrayed a different image of Madonna rather than
her real self. According to Vincent Canby of
The New York Times, Madonna at that time was shrewdly
pragmatic about her persona and appearance—resembling Marilyn
Monroe, but with the "comic tartiness" of Jean Harlow. This
persona was reflected in the second half of the
Who's That Girlfilm. However, the music video chose not
to capture her real self and qualities, or to promote the movie
for which it was specifically created. Instead, it concentrated
on the humerous off-putting personality of Madonna's film
character depicted in the first half of the film. As a result,
the video failed to appeal to people who were not acquainted
with her prior work, nor with people who already knew and
admired Madonna's erotic and funny performance in her music
videos.
Madonna performed the song live only once, on her 1987 Who's
That Girl World Tour. The song was performed as the part of the
encore. The outfit for the performance, designed by Marlene
Stewart, was created with toy watches, plastic lobsters and an
ashtray—thereby depicting her awareness of surrealism.
According to biographer Andrew Morton, it also portrayed her
tongue-in-cheek sense of style: when she bent over in this
ensemble, she revealed panties with the word "Kiss" written on
them. The performance included Madonna dancing around the stage
in the dress and asking the audience to join her. Two different
performances of the song on this tour can be found on the
videos:
Who's That Girl - Live in Japan, filmed in Tokyo, Japan,
on June 22, 1987, and
Ciao, Italia! - Live from Italy, filmed in Turin, Italy,
on September 4, 1987.
The song has been covered many times, mostly on tribute
albums. In 1999, The Countdown Singers made a sound-alike cover
version for the album
Hit Parade of 80's, Vol. 2. The Royal Philharmonic
Orchestra (RPO) made an instrumental version of the song for
the 1998 album
Material Girl: RPO Plays Music of Madonna. German
actress Eva Mattes covered the song for her 2006 album
Language of Love. In 2007, The Bubonic Plague recorded a
cover of the song that was included on the tribute album
Through the Wilderness.